Rent vs. buy calculator

Should You Rent or Buy? Run the Real Numbers.

Monthly rent and a mortgage payment are only the starting line. This calculator compares the full cost of each path over the years you plan to stay, then shows the year buying finally pulls ahead.

Your assumptions

Adjust any figure to update both paths

The purchase

The rental

Your timeline

Buy monthly

$3,792

Principal, interest, tax, insurance

Rent monthly

$2,400

Year one, before annual increases

Renting wins

$23,612

Over 10 years

Net cost over time

Buy Rent

Lower is better. Where the lines cross is your break-even point.

0148.3K296.5KTodayYr 5Yr 10
At these numbers, buying never catches up within 10 years. Extending your timeline or raising the rent assumption can change that.

Year-by-year comparison

Cumulative cost after selling the home versus renting and investing the down payment.

YearNet cost to buyNet cost to rentAdvantage
1$72,560$23,184Rent $49,376
2$97,851$46,895Rent $50,956
3$122,646$71,139Rent $51,507
4$146,917$95,921Rent $50,996
5$170,635$121,245Rent $49,389
6$193,767$147,117Rent $46,650
7$216,281$173,539Rent $42,742
8$238,142$200,515Rent $37,627
9$259,311$228,047Rent $31,264
10$279,748$256,136Rent $23,612

This calculator is an estimate. It assumes you sell at the end of the period and pay selling costs, that the down payment and closing cash would otherwise be invested, and that taxes and maintenance rise with home value. It excludes mortgage insurance, tax deductions, and local fees.

Reading the result

The honest signals on each side

Two households with identical budgets can reach opposite conclusions, because the right answer depends on how long you stay and what the down payment would otherwise be doing.

Buying tends to win when

  • You plan to stay put for five years or more
  • Rent is close to or above the cost of owning
  • You want a fixed housing payment that does not reset each year
  • You have a reserve left after the down payment and closing costs
  • You expect the local market to hold or grow in value

Renting tends to win when

  • You may move, change jobs, or resize within a few years
  • Home prices are stretched compared with local incomes
  • Your down payment would leave you without a cash buffer
  • Maintenance and repairs would strain your monthly budget
  • You value flexibility more than building equity right now

Costs people forget

Four costs that decide the answer

Most rent-versus-buy mistakes come from comparing a mortgage principal and interest figure against a rent check. Include these and the comparison changes.

01

Closing costs

Typically 2–5% of the purchase price in lender fees, title, appraisal, and prepaid items. This cash is gone on day one.

02

Carrying costs

Property tax, insurance, maintenance, and HOA dues continue whether or not the home gains value.

03

Selling costs

Agent commissions and fees often run 6% or more, which is why short holds rarely beat renting.

04

Opportunity cost

Renters keep the down payment invested. That return is a real part of the rent-versus-buy comparison.

Next step: model the mortgage itself

Once buying looks like the better path, check the payment, the amortization schedule, and what extra payments would save you.